Creative Pals ROCKS and you'll find it in the Galleria West shopping center. But don't empty your wallets there. Stop at Kopp's for lunch and don't pass up their homemade frozen custard. There is also a JoAnn Fabrics Superstore in Brookfield on the right side of the road. You'll pass it and Michael's on the way to Creative Pals.
If you feel like venturing out, the scrapbook store in Cedarburg is HUGE. It's called Legacy and is found on Washington Avenue, the main drag. Lots of other shopping (and ice cream) in Cedarburg. Fond du Lac has Scrapbook Cottage and they have tons of Tim Holtz stuff. You'll also find a Hobby Lobby in Racine on Hwy. 20 (exit 333).
Oh, we Cheeseheads are such enablers!! Have a great trip