How neat that you live in such a beautiful place. My husband and I spent most of our honeymoon on Kauai. We absolutely loved it! I would think that any of the women you saw on your island would be great. To be sure, call them and talk to them for a while. You can learn alot from such conversations. After you have talked to all of them, then make your decision.
I guess that you could also look on the page where all the SCS members are listed and see if you recognize a name. HTH,