SU stamp question

[shegadd]

I need help deciding on a stamp set I want to purchase. I like them both but can only manage one at this time. My choices are "Roses in Winter" or "Wild Rose". I like the sentiments with Roses in Winter and both sets seem to be very versitile, I just need help deciding which one to choose. Your opinions would be greatly appreciated! Thanks

[chattiekathie]

I think Roses in Winter is easier to use - JMHO.

[Jeanne S]

Another vote for Roses in Winter

[shegadd]

Thanks, so much the key word in your responses was easier! Roses in Winter it is!

[foodsgal]

Although I don't have it yet, I vote for Roses in Winter too.

[ch]

Another vote for 'Roses in Winter', it is a beautiful set and so fun to play with!

[stamping_KML]

Another vote for Roses In Winter....I LOVE that set!!!

[bluesh4rk]

I vote for Roses In Winter simply because it is in danger to be retired. It is an older set! Not saying it WILL be retired but just a guess on my part. Wild Rose (if I remember correctly) was new last year so it probably won't be retired. But if both are retired, I'll need to buy both cuz I don't have either but want them too! LOL!

[stampinupconsultan]

i agree with blue.... roses in winter has been around for quite some time... years infact, but wild rose is new in this catalog.. should be around for a while.. .I have them both and I love both, but if you can only afford one right now, then get the one in danger and maybe later you can afford the other one.. hope this helps

[shegadd]

Thanks to you all for your help. I am going to order Roses in Winter. My demo said the same thing about a possible retirement because of it's age. I will save up for Wild Roses for a later date. Thanks again!

[Runamok]

I think I am the only one I know who doesn't really care for Roses in Winter--that said, that's the one I would get too, if I were you and liked both, because it is THE rose set everyone (but me) loves. I love the wild rose set, saving my pennies for it and cant wait to get it. But I think that if you like both, go for the Winter roses, you can't go wrong!

[Julz]

Runamok I agree with you, I do not like Roses in Winter, I actually have Wild Rose and love to play with it.

[MikiBee]

Ditto Runomok and Julz, I don't really care for Roses in Winter but I just love Wild Roses.

[nmslmomto3]

I love Roses in Winter only because it seems you can do more with color variations with it, Wild Roses seems to have limitations.

[YouInkIt]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Julz

Runamok I agree with you, I do not like Roses in Winter, I actually have Wild Rose and love to play with it.

Ditto! :-D

[emmiestamps]

Another vote for Roses In Winter! It is such a great set!

[Laurie FW]

Roses in Winter is much easier to use and very pretty, IMHO! Good luck, hope you have fun with whichever one you decide to get!

[Ally]

I just gave Wild Rose away to my best friend, couldn't make a thing with it. Roses in Winter, I love, and I never get tired of. It's way more versatile and it's way easier to make something unique. HTH!

[Stoplightstamper]

I have both. Don't care for Roses in Winter AT ALL. Wasn't sure about Wild Rose till I got it as free mdse. WOW, I love, love, love it!

[Sara in WI]

I love Wild Rose, myself. But go to the Gallery and see what inspires you. That always helps me. (not that I need any help spending money, you understand.....)